View Issue Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0001190||PartDesign||Feature||public||2013-07-27 14:07||2021-02-06 06:43|
|Summary||0001190: Option for PolarPattern to obey individual UpToFirst/UpToLast/UpToFace pad features for each instance.|
Applying a polar pattern to a pad feature in Part Design, it appears that the length is taken from the original feature instead of padding each individual rotated feature to first/last/specific face. In the attached design, if you look inside the hollowed out part, you can see that the two poles, meant to hold screws, are the same height, instead of extending up to the 'ceiling' per 'UpToFirst' pad feature.
polar_bug.fcstd (64,128 bytes)
||@Abdullah when you get a moment please check this ticket. Thanks!|
I think I understand what the reporter wanted to do. I am not sure how this should actually work.
The first pad goes up to first. Now, I am not sure whether the transformation should "recompute" where it should end or not. I mean, I understand it would be useful for the case of the reporter. I simply do not know how general such a case is.
I think it is worth to involve one of the CAD experts to gather more information about user requirements.
||I'll test in the commercial CAD software I use at work and report back.|
||FYI, there is a simple workaround here since there are only two occurrences, delete the polar pattern and add a second circle in Sketch016031002. Two posts will be created up to the face of the inner loft.|
||@vnks please respond|
Forgot to report back. In the commercial parametric CAD program I use at work, the behaviour is as the reporter is asking. The transformation is recomputed according to the ending condition of the original pad.
Maybe this could be considered an enhancement request rather than a bug.
||Changed to 'Feature'|
||Opened forum thread for further discussion: https://forum.freecadweb.org/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=29035|
||@NormandC how would you rename this ticket to reflect that it's a feature instead of something missing in FC ?|
||Renamed ticket title per the chrisb's recommendation in the forum|
|2013-07-27 14:07||vnks||New Issue|
|2013-07-27 14:07||vnks||File Added: polar_bug.fcstd|
|2017-05-31 22:19||Kunda1||Note Added: 0009232|
|2017-06-10 23:29||abdullah||Note Added: 0009340|
|2017-06-17 21:46||normandc||Note Added: 0009427|
|2017-06-17 21:49||normandc||Note Added: 0009428|
|2017-06-18 17:20||Kunda1||Tag Attached: PolarPattern|
|2017-06-21 10:51||Kunda1||Status||new => feedback|
|2017-06-21 10:51||Kunda1||Note Added: 0009479|
|2017-08-02 11:02||normandc||Note Added: 0009863|
|2017-08-02 11:02||normandc||Note Edited: 0009863|
|2017-08-02 14:00||Kunda1||Category||Bug => Feature|
|2017-08-02 14:00||Kunda1||Note Added: 0009868|
|2018-05-31 00:27||Kunda1||Tag Attached: #pending|
|2018-05-31 00:31||Kunda1||Note Added: 0011321|
|2018-10-08 14:17||Kunda1||Note Added: 0011971|
|2019-03-03 14:19||Kunda1||Severity||major => minor|
|2019-03-03 14:19||Kunda1||Status||feedback => acknowledged|
|2019-03-03 14:19||Kunda1||Product Version||trunk =>|
|2019-03-03 14:19||Kunda1||Summary||Polar pattern doesn't obey UpToFirst/UpToLast/UpToFace pad features => Option for PolarPattern to obey individual UpToFirst/UpToLast/UpToFace pad features for each instance.|
|2019-03-03 14:19||Kunda1||Note Added: 0012831|
|2019-03-03 14:19||Kunda1||Tag Detached: #pending|
|2021-02-06 06:43||abdullah||Target Version||=> 0.20|